Skip advertisement Advertisement

New York Sour

Difford’s Guide
Discerning Drinkers (241)
Measurements in:
Serves:
1
Ingredients
2 fl oz Bourbon whiskey
1 fl oz Lemon juice (freshly squeezed)
1/2 fl oz Sugar syrup 'rich' (2 sugar to 1 water) 65.0°Brix
1 dash Angostura Aromatic Bitters
1/2 fl oz Egg white (pasteurised) or Fee Brothers Fee Foam cocktail foamer (optional)
1/2 fl oz Claret wine (Bordeaux red) (chilled)

How to make

Glassware

Serve in an Old-fashioned glass

Prepare

  1. Select and pre-chill an OLD-FASHIONED GLASS.
  2. Prepare garnish of lemon zest twist.

Method

  1. SHAKE first 5 ingredients with ice and strain back into shaker.
  2. DRY SHAKE (without ice) to emulsify.
  3. FINE STRAIN into ice-filled glass.
  4. DRIZZLE red wine around the surface of the cocktail.

Garnish

  1. EXPRESS lemon zest twist over the cocktail and use as garnish.

Flavour Profile

No alcohol
Medium
Boozy
Strength 6/10
Sweet
Medium
Dry/sour
Sweet to sour 7/10

Health & Nutrition

Nutrition:

One serving of New York Sour contains 223 calories

Alcohol content:

  • 1.6 standard drinks
  • 15.81% alc./vol. (31.61° proof)
  • 23 grams of pure alcohol

Allergens:

Recipe contains the following allergens:

Skip advertisement Advertisement

History

Thought to have been first made in the 1880s by a bartender in Chicago, this drink was originally named the Continental Sour and then Southern Whiskey Sour, also masquerading as a Brunswick Sour and Claret Snap before becoming best known as the New York Sour, probably after a bartender in Manhattan started serving the drink and made it popular. It first appears in print under the New York Sour name in print in the 1934 Mr. Boston Bartender's Guide.
History of Sours family of cocktails and more recipies

Review

A classic bourbon-based Whiskey Sour made more interesting – both visually and in flavour by the addition of a float of red wine.

Egg white is not classically used in a New York Sour but some prefer this drink with the mouthfeel and change of appearance egg white imparts.

British bartenders may prefer the following formula based on UK measures:
50 ml Bourbon whiskey
25 ml Lemon juice
12.5 ml Sugar syrup (2:1)
1 dash Angostura bitters
12.5 ml Egg white (optional)
12.5 ml Claret red wine

AKA: Brunswick Sour; Chicago Sour; Claret Snap; Continental Sour; Southern

Variations/similar cocktails

Brunswick (a rye whiskey sour with a red wine float but with no egg white)
Continental Sour (a whiskey sour with a port wine float)
Greenwich Sour (a rye whiskey sour with egg white and a red wine float)
New York Stone Sour (a New York Sour with apricot liqueur and orange juice)
New Yorker (a New York Sour served straight-up with orange juice)

Skip advertisement Advertisement
Skip advertisement Advertisement

Comments & Discussion

Chris Dimal
The egg white version is my preference. Makes it silky. The only thing is perhaps more red wine (like the Greenwich Sour).
score: 1
Bocman
Classic and excellent! 👌
Since I don’t have wine, I just use a rosso vermouth. 😅
score: 1
Zach Schwartz
No need to be picky with the wine style on this one. I typically use Costco Kirkland Cabernet Sauvignon or Bota Box Shiraz and it’s fantastic.
score: 1
Simon Sedgley Premium Member
We tried this exceptional cocktail substituting Madeira for the Claret. Not as visually stunning but delicious for us. Drop the Madeira down to 10.0-12.5ml if you wish.
score: 1
Henry Tran
Made with this ratio and quite happy with it too:

45 ml Irish Whiskey
22.5 ml lemon juice
15 ml rich Demerara syrup
15 ml egg white
22.5 ml red wine float
Lemon oil
score: 2
David Selle Premium Member
I like to swap out the sugar syrup for maple syrup, it's quite good this way (may need to adjust the amount depending on your syrup).
score: 3
Clarence Castillo
Thanks in advance, or maybe thanks retroactively to Russell Lee. I haven't actually encountered whiskey barrel finished red wines, but maybe I haven't been looking in the right places? I'm going to try this with Old Elk wheated Bourbon and a smooth yet tannic and light bodied well-aged Haute Medoc.
score: 3
Clarence Castillo
Well now we are getting somewhere! It tastes great and the layering effect in the glass is gorgeous. It's not really a "sour" cocktail though, and perhaps that's the key? Compared to a daiquiri or old-school whiskey sour, the tartness is barely noticeable, more akin to what you might encounter in a Witbeir or Saison.
score: 3
Russell Lee
Awesome! Glad it shook out well for you! And yes, I definitely don't view this drink as your typical Sour, as it is kind of an entirely different beast with the wine of your choice in the mix.

In fact, when I serve this to guests, I almost treat it as a dessert on its own - might also have something to do with the fact that I like to serve this drink in a red wine balloon glasses that hold a lot more volume than a rocks glass, and using upwards of 1 oz (or more) of red wine - but hey, to each our own. :)
score: 2
Michael Zanfardino
Super refreshing Sour. The wine float gives the drink an unexpected apple note - very tasty. Good late summer/early fall vibes.
score: 1
Matija Prelec
This drink is one of my favourites, but made with tawny port. That adds such a layer of flavour and complexity, I cannot recommend it enough.
score: 5
Clarence Castillo
I'm intrigued by the New York Sour but I've never made or been served a great one. I assume it succeeds or fails on the compatibility of the Bourbon and "Claret red wine." Could we clarify in more modern language what red wine would work well in this cocktail? A California Cabernet? A South Australian Shiraz? And what about substituting Rye for Bourbon. Rye seems more "New York."
score: 3
Russell Lee
When I made this a few weeks ago, I used Canadian Club 12 year as my base (fairly mellow, medium rye spice in a mixed mashbill), which paired nicely with Jacob’s Creek Double Barrel Shiraz (Australian, and finished in whiskey barrels). It was definitely a full-bodied drink as a whole - the shiraz adding deep plum fruit and chocolate notes - I quite liked it. Whiskey-barrel-finished reds are pretty commonplace (but not all are equal) among many brands and varietals, but definitely experiment! My choices may not scream “New York” but if this drink is Chicagoan in actual origin anyways - well, whatever tastes great!
score: 4
Simon Sedgley Premium Member
Well, "Claret wine (Bordeaux red)" would translate most closely downunder to a Coonawarra or Margaret River Cabernet Sauvignon. A Loire Valley Cabernet Franc (a parent of Cabernet Sauvignon) would, we think, be worth a try also.
score: 1
Andre Derailleur Premium Member
Yes, despite living near Maragaret River I just made it with Coonawarra Cabernet. It is one of my favourites, with or without egg white. However I am beginning to prefer rye whiskey versions which just seem to have a little extra spice.
score: 1

Showing the first 10 of 17 comments.