Simon Sedgley avatar
Simon Sedgley

Simon Sedgley

  • Premium Member
  • Commenter #5
  • Appreciated Commenter #5
  • Conversation Starter #4
Golden Martini
12 Comments

Spanish is not my language but the creator, Angel, appears to be suggesting a variant that would substitute elderflower liqueur for the curacao. Has our good host explored this possibility?

Gypsy No. 1
19 Comments
Paul King

Had to substitute the green Chartreuse with Italicus, and it works a treat.

We enjoyed it, but not as much as the original. We upped the Italicus to 10ml in an attempt to achieve the original's balance. Not close enough to our taste.

Simon Sedgley

A big sour and wonderfully balanced. Do it with Morgenthaler's lime cordial recipe and you will be dancing. We have yet to observe a bottle of Oude Genever find its way South of the equator to within grasping distance of us downunder. So this, rather than our good host's, recipe is the one we happily go with.

Simon Sedgley

We wonder if a drop or two of grapefruit bitters might not go astray...next time.

Simon Sedgley

A big sour and wonderfully balanced. Do it with Morgenthaler's lime cordial recipe and you will be dancing. We have yet to observe a bottle of Oude Genever find its way South of the equator to within grasping distance of us downunder. So this, rather than our good host's, recipe is the one we happily go with.

Chris Dimal

I have to ask, which lime cordial are you using? Because when you use a good lime cordial (I made my own with Jeffrey Morgenthaler's recipe), it was fresh yet had this bracing sweet-sour quality that truly shone in this drink, even popping the orange out of the Curacao.

Simon Sedgley

So we made the syrup according to Morgenthaler's recipe and included it in the cocktail as specified in its recipe. The syrup is wonderfully flavoursome and with it the cocktail does come alive. Thanks again for the tip. And now, a Gimlet anyone?

Calvin Grant

Thanks. Thats what I used most recently. Need to get the Heering and try them side by side.

Simon Sedgley

Let us all know what you decide. It's all down to personal taste, of course, but we prefer the bright expressiveness of the Luxardo.

Damn It Jimmy
27 Comments
trendomexico

I am discovering taste variations & uses of Sherry, so I was recommended to came here. I get a Sake bottle in my weekly bar replenish. I was very afraid since it does sound well the combination... AND SURPRISE is amazing, tasty, elegant, surprising, is really a new classic. five stars deme 10 de estos para llevar!

Simon Sedgley

Unlike a beautifully statuesque woman, Sake doesn't age well. So to enjoy and finish your bottle in its youthful and ephemeral, blushing prime, maybe stir a "For Mezcalicus Sake". Salud.

El Guapo
1 Comment
Simon Sedgley

So good. But without all of the 'trimmings' it would fit snugly into a Nick and Nora glass. Wanting a bit more, we upped each of the liquid ingredients by a third and served in a large Rocks Glass. Delicious for us.

Veritas
4 Comments
Simon Sedgley

We raised the Gin to 45ml and added a few drops of grapefruit bitters. Much more characterful for us. We might try it with a lemon and grapefruit juice split next time...lime juice in the wrong place can be a bit one-dimensional.

Simon Sedgley

Really delicious...Sotol is very expressive, in a lighthearted way. We included the Angostura garnish (6 drops), as per Valencia's original recipe...for us it adds a necessary complexity.

Tailspin
2 Comments
Simon Sedgley

Really superb balance here for us. We used Punt e Mes in place of the Carpano as the latter is sometimes a bit too expressive of vanilla for our taste. And for the red bitter we went with Gran Classico, which we think suits a drink that is presenting itself as rounded and slightly voluptuous. With the somewhat austere ones we reach for the Campari. Sadly Strucchi is not available to us downunder.

Call London
3 Comments
trendomexico

Angela Landsbuty travels in her bed in Bedknobs and Broomsticks, I do the same with my shaker! I love this version of Call London even much better than London Calling! I am discovering the Jerez in all versions. Jerez - Sherry not Cherry and sometimes Manzanilla, I just bought each version, and I am doing all kind of recipes. Recommend me some please por favor senior :D

Simon Sedgley

Well, if you can lay your hands on a bottle of sake, then maybe make a "Damn it Jimmy". Hands down our favourite 'Martini', the recipe brought to us by our good host.

Chris Dimal

I have to ask, which lime cordial are you using? Because when you use a good lime cordial (I made my own with Jeffrey Morgenthaler's recipe), it was fresh yet had this bracing sweet-sour quality that truly shone in this drink, even popping the orange out of the Curacao.

Simon Sedgley

We don't use lime cordial at all, since all of the commercial ones we've ever tried are, to our taste, terrible. We weren't aware of the Morgenthaler recipe and, since we make our own passionfruit and lemon syrups, will give it a go. Thanks a lot for the tip.

Ember and Cream
2 Comments
Simon Sedgley

Tonight we had a cold southerly wind insinuating itself through the gaps in our windows and under our doors. So we made this warming comfort drink which we enjoyed immensely, although our creation fell way short, in appearance, of the posh looking one in the photo. So bravo. And a question: is it intended that the orange swatch find its way into the drink or be discarded? We discarded.

Lisa Smith

6 drops of bitters has to make quite an impact on the drink. Any suggestions for a substitute if Bob's Ginseng bitters aren't available?

Simon Sedgley

We didn't have the Ginseng Bitters and have no idea what they taste like. But we wanted to include bitters so, purely speculatively, we added 2 drops Daiquiri Bitters and 1 drop Ginger Bitters, both Bob's. Worked just fine for us.

Beach House
3 Comments
Simon Sedgley

A very, very pleasant easy drinking cocktail. No fireworks, just pitch-perfect and subtle balance. We didn't have passionfruit syrup (which we sometimes make) and so we substituted 7.5ml of Chinola liqueur. If you're the shy, retiring type maybe this is the Margarita for you.

Simon Sedgley

A fun party drink. Nothing complicated here but it's nicely balanced and easy drinking as our good host says. We amped up Selena's decibels slightly by adding a gentle float of Falernum.