Paul MATEJCEK avatar
Paul MATEJCEK

Paul MATEJCEK

METRO MILWAUKEE (WISCONSIN, USA), United States

  • Premium Member
  • Appreciated Commenter #469
  • Conversation Starter #187
Gin Basil Sour
3 Comments
Peter McCarthy

Like most recipes with leaves, there's a lot of room for variability (leaf sizes, muddling length/intensity, etc.) (especially so with the recipe calling for 12). More precision would be nice, otherwise this may require some experimentation to achieve balance. Nonetheless, a nice option if you're in the mood for a refreshing basil drink, especially at the end of a hot summer day.

Paul MATEJCEK

Peter, I understand your concern, and I share it. It's as bad a "juice of half a (lime, lemon, whatever)". But what can be done? It's easy to specify a volume of juice, but what could be done about leaves? And what about the variability of muddling technique? I don't see a solution. For me, I sometimes make dated notes on the recipe, just as I do when 'tuning' someone else's recipe to my (or my wife's!) tastes. Sometimes the outcome is multiple variations. In my case, that would include margaritas and daiquiris.

Orange Whip
4 Comments
Paul MATEJCEK

¼ barspoon of xanthan gum?
If you are lucky enough, like me, to own an Easy Jigger, and the author was referring to an 'American barspoon,' then you can measure 1/24 ounce.

If a Barspoon = 5 ml
then ¼ Barspoon = 1.25 ml = 0.042 oz (approx 1/24 oz)

If a Barspoon = 2.5 ml
then ¼ Barspoon = 0.625 ml = 0.0211 oz (approx 1/48 oz)

If a Barspoon = 2.4 ml = 1/8 oz
then ¼ Barspoon = 0.6 ml = 0.02 oz (approx 1/50 oz)

Paper Plane
78 Comments
Paul MATEJCEK

Bourbon, Campari, Aperol, and lemon juice make a fine Paper Plane! Some folks on the west coast are replacing the lemon with lime, calling it Ruby Sippers.

Luxardo Maraschino liqueur
Not yet rated
9 Comments
Paul MATEJCEK

I plan to look for Luxardo every time I go into a bar, and when I find it, I'll taste it. I saw it in so many recipes that I bought a bottle. I think it's nasty. My wife thinks it's disgusting. So I keep wondering if I might possibly have gotten a bad bottle. But I'm not going to invest in a second one to find out!

Six Cylinder
10 Comments
Paul MATEJCEK

Any thoughts about a sub for the Dubonnet? Punt e Mes? Noilly Prat? Pimm's #1? Maybe Aperol? ...or must I wait until I get my hands onto the real McCoy?

Paper Plane
78 Comments
Paul MATEJCEK

Bulleit (Rye or Bourbon, depending), Campari, Aperol (or Peychaud's Apperitivo), and fresh lemon. It always amazes me how much this concoction tastes like *grapefruit*, of all things. Everyone I've made it for, so far, loves it. It's easy to make, and your friends will think you're a superstar. Just don't tell them the ingredients, unless they are adventurous.

Fourth Regiment
14 Comments
Paul MATEJCEK

I made up a similar bent Manhattan 5 years ago, almost to the day. It's my '3-2-1 Manahattan.'

3 oz rye
2 oz sweet vermouth
1 oz dry vermouth

3 dashes orange bitter
2 dashes Peychaud’s bitters
1 dash Angostura bitters

¾ oz cherry juice (optional)

Paul MATEJCEK

This cocktail has been a wonderful addition to my “All-Star” list.
As an All Star, I’ll make minor adjustments, and take notes on the outcomes, until I’ve found what’s perfect for us. For instance, demerara is good – but it adds an extra complexity that might be a distraction, so I’ll give simple syrup a try. Bourbon or rye? A gentler, more rounded whisky, or something that announces its presence with elbows up? The bottom line is that this cocktail is a keeper.