Join thousands of fellow Discerning Drinkers. Save your favourite cocktails, keep a wish list, rate recipes, receive our weekly newsletter and much more. It’s free to join.
The amaro matters. I didn’t have any Lucano, so I subbed in Averna. That didn’t work, too syrupy. Then I went out and got myself a bottle of Baulio (Simon mentions that the original Treadway recipe actually called for Braulio, not Lucano). This made a huge difference— not too sweet, plenty of piney “alpine” notes. Definitely a keeper!