Forum

26th August at 12:36
On the strength of commentor Calvin Grant's observation on this cocktail and it appearing in our good host's "Top Twenty Vodka Cocktails", we thought we might have been a bit harsh in our earlier judgment about it. Revisiting it, we remain unconvinced. To us, this tastes like a Sidecar variant in which the Vodka and citrus aren't standing up to the Benedictine. Our solution was to split the citrus 50:50 (15ml each). This was much better for us. Maybe introducing lime juice into the mix would also be worth a try.
7th September at 03:08
Ok. Tried again original specs. (with white grapefruit, prefer pink). The Benedictine/Bob's grapefruit bitters are a feature, not a flaw, and I like them up front. Couldn't taste them with the added lemon juice. Otherwise it's just another sour. ★★★★★♥︎
7th September at 12:40
It's a jumping off point for an interesting conversation, probably too long for this comments section, and one which could go in a number of directions. Our sense of taste, for each of us, is uniquely sensual and nuanced. Hence the old and true saying: "There's no accounting for taste." But, as our good host rightly insists, the challenge is to grow discerning, not according to some ideal formula but in loyalty to our own true and unique taste. So here's to yours.
7th September at 02:44
Did try the 50/50 citrus split. This was good and then it was gone. Couldn't put it down. The lemon kind of dominated the grapefruit but I could still taste it. Surely the Benedictine was still in there, I find it hard to define sometimes, like it's the bones of the structure. Maybe 10ml lemon, 20ml pink grapefruit? Doesn't anybody use white grapefruit anymore? Will try this next with the original specs. Cheers!
30th August at 03:26
Intriguing, look forward to trying.