Tried with Appleton Estate 12 year and Rittenhouse Rye. It's okay, but I prefer a regular sazerac. I'm starting to think I only like Jamaican rum in mai tais.
I'm with John on this one. Made mine with Rittenhouse and Smith & Cross. The S&C brings that Jamaican funk that stands up to the Rittenhouse BinB. Need two heavyweights or one's going to overpower the other.