Tasted Bonal, Byrrh and Dubonnet head to head.
Bonal is brownish, with a nice, sweet, fruity/plummy flavor. A hint of bitterness, not syrupy/cloying. Excellent.
Byrrh is the lightest color – ruby/reddish. Light and fruity flavor (weirdly like Cocchi Americano, but the wrong color), with some drying bitterness. Delicious.
Dubonnet is dark burgundy/maroon, and is the most sweet & fruity (not cloying). Excellent.
The 3 are cousins, but not subs for each other.
I saw this in the shelf of my supermarket and was so happy to see Dubonnet there. Of course, I bought a bottle and took it home. What an absolute abomination! It is quite disgusting and bears no resemblance to genuine Dubonnet. What on earth is Pernod Ricard thinking? Yuk!
I believe the US rights to Dubonnet were sold some decades ago, perhaps even before Pernod Ricard acquired the brand. I agree with you, the US version is a poor rendition on the French-made original.
Bonal is brownish, with a nice, sweet, fruity/plummy flavor. A hint of bitterness, not syrupy/cloying. Excellent.
Byrrh is the lightest color – ruby/reddish. Light and fruity flavor (weirdly like Cocchi Americano, but the wrong color), with some drying bitterness. Delicious.
Dubonnet is dark burgundy/maroon, and is the most sweet & fruity (not cloying). Excellent.
The 3 are cousins, but not subs for each other.