Ian Cummins avatar
Ian Cummins

Ian Cummins

  • Appreciated Commenter #592
  • Conversation Starter #712
Fancy Free
24 Comments
Ian Cummins

Upsetting and perfume-y. Undrinkable. I tried rescuing it by turning it into a long drink with soda water, but that didn't help either.

Ian Cummins

I built this cocktail looking to find some sort of use for my creme de menthe that wasn't just a grasshopper.

As-is, I found it too rich and it turned my stomach - a rare experience for myself.

I highly recommend trying turning this into a long drink. Fill a glass with ice, pour this in, and fill with sparkling water - I used a grapefruit seltzer to great effect, but even unflavored would improve this drink greatly.

Otherwise, I would skip. I wanted *so* badly for this to be good as-is, but it is incredibly far from the mark. I would avoid experimenting with this unless you could turn it into a long drink if you don't like it.

Beatnik
12 Comments
Ian Cummins

I challenge you to make this with any fortified wine, similarly to how you can change the amaro used. It may come out sweeter, the walnut bitters others have mentioned would balance it out nicely.

M & M
28 Comments
Ian Cummins

Had a shot both with ice (as per the instructions) and neat, using Vecchio Amaro del Campo and Banhez mezcal, and it was amazing. Strangely enough, I think I may prefer it neat.

M & M
28 Comments
Gabrielle14

Swapped Montenegro for Vecchio Amaro Del Capo and wow! So much more depth, less sweet and complex. Highly recommend.

Ian Cummins

Wow, you're right on the money. On top of that, it drinks so nicely neat.