The balance between sweet and sour is crucial to the majority of cocktails and consistently producing balanced cocktails is made easier when using sugar syrup with a known and constant sweetness.
Sugar syrups tend to be made according to two recipes:
One part sugar to one part water (1:1)
1:1 syrup can be made by shaking sugar and room-temperature water together in a sealed container, so it is appropriately known as 'simple syrup'.
1:1 is the most common type of syrup used in American bars (but even in America, there is a growing trend towards the use of 2:1 syrup). The appeal of 1:1 syrup is that no heat is needed to dissolve the sugar in the water and 1oz (30ml) of "simple syrup" roughly balances the acidity of 1oz (30ml) citrus juice so making balanced cocktail recipes easy.
Two parts sugar to one part water (2:1)
Known as "rich sugar syrup," 2:1 is the most common sugar syrup found outside America and is the style used in Difford's Guide recipes.
When measured by volume rather than mass [see below], 2:1 sugar syrup is also around the same degree of sweetness found in most commercially produced bottled sugar syrups. European bars commonly buy syrup rather than make their own to help ensure consistency, and syrups are widely stocked in supermarkets. The willingness to buy rather than make syrups is also driven by the fact that making 2:1 syrup involves the faff of gently heating and stirring the water and sugar to ensure all the sugar dissolves.
20ml (2/3oz) of "rich syrup" roughly balances the acidity of 30ml (1oz) citrus juice.
2:1 'rich' syrup versus 1:1 'simple' syrup
2:1 syrup is superior to 1:1 syrup as the use of 1:1 sugar syrup adds additional, perhaps unwanted, dilution to a drink compared to 2:1 syrup, typically around 5 to 8%, depending on the recipe. It's a small percentage but worth eliminating. If desirable in a particular cocktail, dilution can be controllably increased by adding a measured amount of chilled water. If you worry about over-dilution from "wet" melting ice, then you should also consider the amount of water in your sugar syrup.
Converting cocktail recipes using 2:1 rich syrup to equivalent 1:1 simple syrup
Confusingly, if a cocktail recipe specifies 10ml of 2:1 rich sugar syrup, the equivalent is NOT 20ml of 1:1 as would seem logical but nearer to 15ml of 1:1 (actually 13.56ml) simple syrup. 2:1 sugar syrup is 1.35 times sweeter than 1:1 syrup (not twice as sweet).
A liquid's sweetness is measured on a scale called 'brix'.
2:1 rich sugar syrup (by volume) = 65.1°brix
1:1 simple sugar syrup (by volume) = 48.0°brix
The difference in brix between the two concentrations of sugar syrup illustrates that 1:1 simple syrup is 26.27% less sweet than 2:1 rich syrup. And conversely, 2:1 is a little more than a third sweeter (35.62%) than 1:1 simple syrup.
Equivalent sweetness rounding to nearest bar measure
5ml (1 barspoon) 2:1 syrup = 7.5ml (¼oz) 1:1 syrup
7.5ml (1/4oz) 2:1 syrup = 10ml (1/3oz 1:1 syrup
10ml (1/3oz) 2:1 syrup = 15ml (½oz) 1:1 syrup
15ml (½oz) 2:1 syrup = 20ml (2/3oz) 1:1 syrup
20ml (2/3oz) 2:1 syrup = 30ml (1oz) 1:1 syrup
Measuring by volume rather than mass
When making sugar syrup, some people measure by weight (e.g. 2kg of sugar to 1kg of water), while others measure by volume (e.g. 2 cups of sugar to 1 cup of water). Whether following a 1:1 or 2:1 ratio, measuring by weight results in a sweeter syrup than that made by measuring by volume.
For ease and to produce a 65°brix syrup, I measure by volume – 2 cups of sugar to 1 cup of water.
Comments & Discussion
Also, rich simple syrup doesn’t have to be raised to high temperatures. Magnetic stirrers used be quite expensive, so much so that labs would often make their own using used CPU fans, but that is no longer the cas.
Dilution with 1-1 syrups is minimal. If you use an ounce of syrup in a cocktail, (usually it's less) you are only adding 1/3 of an ounce of extra water. My admittedly limited practical experiments with side-by-side blind tastings of the same drink made with 1-1 and 2-1 syrups resulted in the two being indistinguishable by everyone I asked to try them. Maybe there are super tasters that can tell the difference, but most mere mortals can't. Also, if you are using 2-1 syrups in the cocktails where you actually want the increased dilution for some reason, adding chilled water is just an extra annoying step.
I suppose there might be some recipes that are riding the bleeding edge of dilution where the difference might be noticeable, but those are probably few and far between, and you can usually take the water out elsewhere. Anything with orange juice comes to mind, but the solution there is to acid adjust the OJ and let the extra water come out of the lime/lemon juice you don't have to use to balance the sweetness.
The real reason though is that heat is your enemy. Heating to make 2-1 syrups actually changes the sugar, and with it the flavor. Plus, 2-1 syrups aren't really shelf stable and will crash out eventually, requiring reheating to put them back into solution, further degrading the sugar.
Low/no heat syrups just taste better, IMO, particularly fruit syrups. Syrups made with 'juicy' fruits, like most berries, stone fruits, etc., can be made with no heat at all, just like oleo saccharum. Macerate the fruit and mix with sugar. Let sit for a day or so on the counter or in the fridge while the sugar pulls the juices and fruit sugars out of the fruit. Strain/filter the solids out and dilute to 50 Brix. The result is a much more intense and brighter syrup than anything heated will be. Plus you can use the solids as a spread for toast. If you try to heat these syrups enough to make them 2-1 you will cook the flavor right out of them.
Some fruits need heat for a good extraction, but adding any kind of heat at all to fruit syrups risks activating the pectin and making jelly. Cranberries will start to gel up even at 140F in a sous vide cooker, as I have repeatedly proven :-/ (They are safe at 120F). Same for rhubarb. Some fruits require a bit higher temperature for good extraction, but never above 140F. Grenadine needs some heat to get the pomegranate molasses to fully incorporate, and I make a syrup with Chinese plums, licorice and hawthorn that needs heat to speed up the rehydration of the dried fruits. Even hard ingredient extractions, like cinnamon and coconut, work better at low heat. The cinnamon flavors extracted at 140F are much more nuanced than the monotone 'red hot candy' flavor that you get at high heat. Low and slow, just like BBQ, is the ticket.
The only syrup that I make using high heat is ginger. Using pressed ginger juice or low heat extraction for ginger syrup produces a flavor that is much too sharp compared to the sweetness of the syrup, which ends up overwhelming the cocktail. The pronounced change in flavor that heating causes actually works better to create a balanced ginger syrup, IMO.
Hopefully I have convinced you that 'flavored' syrups are better with minimal heating, so 50 Brix -- but why not make your 'regular' syrups, like simple, turbinado, honey, agave, and maple at 67 Brix? For me it's just easier for all my syrups to have the same sweetness. When I'm working up a cocktail recipe, one of the first things I do is balance the sweetness. Once that is set, if I want to use the sweetener to add a flavor, I don't want the extra hassle of changing the amount required. Their shelf life is comparable, and if refrigerated, measured in months. I just don't see the advantage of 2-1 syrups.
By the way, the 2nd last comment here was 3 weeks ago so people barely comment here, but I came here when you posted your comment just 11 seconds ago! What a coincidence haha
I will be following your advice in the future.
When substituting coarse "Kosher" or flake salt for finer "table salt" in cooking, one source says to be sure to double the volume amount, as the larger crystals end up delivering less salt to the dish.
If this is true, it would make sense to me that using coarse vs. fine sugar would yield a syrup that is less sweet.
I haven't tried this, so I don't know for sure.
Showing the first 10 of 14 comments.
View full discussion in the forum