Andre Derailleur avatar
Andre Derailleur

Andre Derailleur

Western Australia, Australia

  • Premium Member
  • Commenter #27
  • Appreciated Commenter #28
  • Conversation Starter #35
New York Sour
17 Comments
Simon Sedgley

Our Rye Whiskey Sour recipe is:
60ml Rittenhouse Rye
30ml lemon juice
15ml sugar syrup
1 barspoon Luxardo Maraschino Cherries syrup
3 dashes Peychaud's Bitters
Garnish with a Maraschino cherry
We notice that there is a community recipe contributed by Phil Mackenzie which is similar. But (and we admit that we may not have searched as scrupulously as we might have) our good host doesn't appear to have posted a simple Rye Whiskey Sour.

Andre Derailleur

Sounds great. I'm on to it. Mind you any drink with Rittenhouse is likely to be pretty good.

New York Sour
17 Comments
Simon Sedgley

Well, "Claret wine (Bordeaux red)" would translate most closely downunder to a Coonawarra or Margaret River Cabernet Sauvignon. A Loire Valley Cabernet Franc (a parent of Cabernet Sauvignon) would, we think, be worth a try also.

Andre Derailleur

Yes, despite living near Maragaret River I just made it with Coonawarra Cabernet. It is one of my favourites, with or without egg white. However I am beginning to prefer rye whiskey versions which just seem to have a little extra spice.

Frisky Bison
2 Comments
Simon Difford

Thanks, John. I've reduced all quantities by a 1/3 so it better fits the glass and I'll reshoot the image in the coming weeks. Present photo is pre-digital photography.

Andre Derailleur

The “shot/parts” measurement says 11/3 which is nearly 4 shots of vodka!

Andre Derailleur

No falernum, but ChatGPT recommended pimento dram and clove garnish as a substitute. A pleasant margarita with some spice. I think I will stick to standard margarita on the rocks or Tommy’s margarita.

Bronx (Difford's)
15 Comments
Simon Sedgley

An enigmatic cocktail, complex and subtle. For us, it was a bit scattered straight out of the shaker. So our humble advice is to just let it rest a minute or two after pouring and allow the drop in temperature to bring everything into a lovely balance.

Andre Derailleur

I’m not sure the complexity produces a great drink. Mind you I am a bit wary of mixing dry and sweet vermouths: it usually doesn’t work for me.

Elder & Wiser
8 Comments
Andre Derailleur

The whiskey elder and apple combination is tasty, but very sweet as specified. I preferred a 4:1:1 ratio with a slice of lemon to add just a touch of acid, plus a dash of bitters to give some more depth.

Paper Plane
82 Comments
Andre Derailleur

So Antoni makes a point: how does this "riff" have no ingredients in common with the 'Last Word" Is it just the proportions, because I am sure we could name dozens of other drinks with the same proportions.

Rated this four as specified, but the tried reversing the proportions of schnapps and vermouth. Now I rate it five: vanilla, then vermouth like a vodka martini followed with a restrained apple sweetness. I did use my homemade crab apple liqueur.

Petanque cocktail
7 Comments
Simon Sedgley

Light as a feather yet delightfully tasty. Some cocktails just have a bit of magic about them. We used a Rutherglen aged dry flor which made the tasty tasty-tasty.

Andre Derailleur

Used a Spanish sherry, but naked amaretto from Altona, of all places. Lovely after dinner.

Red Raider
5 Comments
Simon Sedgley

As with tomato and basil, Bourbon and Grenadine were made for each other. We went with lime instead of lemon, thinking that the citrus needed a bit more kick to stand up to the prescribed volume of Grenadine. A very delicious cocktail.

Andre Derailleur

Have homemade grenadine and it was great with this, though I did enjoy a small extra slug of whiskey.

Sloe Cup
1 Comment
Andre Derailleur

Sloe gin certainly complimented the plum. I needed. Splash more whiskey to balance the ginger ale. I didn’t put half a shot of peychauds in, but three dashes seemed enough. Lovely drink.