Chris Dimal avatar
Chris Dimal

Chris Dimal

  • Commenter #7
  • Appreciated Commenter #7
  • Conversation Starter #6
Clover Club
13 Comments

I'm going to say a very unpopular opinion: orange (or in my case Mandarin juice) really is a good addition to the Clover Club. I did only add 5ml of it, but it somehow makes the drink even juicier and delicious.

East India No.1
5 Comments

Obviously like many, couldn't find Red Curacao. What I decided to do was to add some Creme de Cacao to add some levity and a point of difference. The raspberry syrup I had made it red anyway. It was a decent drink, though the No. 2 is better.

Gimlet
3 Comments

I had the 5:3 gin to cordial recipe. It was fine, but I still miss the prick and the pop of what the platonic ideal of a Gimlet should be. I still think that Raymond Chandler's description is what the Gimlet should be: sweet and sharp.

Gimlet
3 Comments

I had the 5:3 gin to cordial recipe. It was fine, but I still miss the prick and the pop. Raymond Chandler's recipe is exactly what I think of what a Gimlet should be. Sweet and sharp. I still think either 1:1.5 or 1:1 with navy strength gin is the way to go.

Ti Punch
17 Comments
Chris Dimal

I think this drink may just exemplify my weak, wet palate. It was a difficult drink for me. The first thing is it's too sweet. I already had a hunch, hence I upped to 60ml. It starts so strong and overwhelming, like a piranha biting my throat off, but then it finishes so cloyingly sweet. I reduced the syrup to 5ml, was only a little better. Yeah, this was a struggle.

Mulled Negroni
9 Comments
Matt

Not really as over-spiced as "mulled" would imply - this is clearly a negroni, but with some additional sweetness and spice, esp from the sloe gin and falernum. A very nice, seasonal variant.

Chris Dimal

I 100% agree with your review. It's a Negroni, but so distinctive as well.

Pisco Sour
15 Comments
Chris Dimal

Didn't do the orange blossom water and used a Quebranta Pisco that was actually made by Bodega San Nicolas (of 1615 fame, so not the greatest quality, but I did get it for really cheap) for a Peruvian restaurant in our area. Even then, wow! I loved this mix of verdant yet fresh, floral yet fruity, slightly musty thing that the Pisco provides to this sour. So complex and moreish. I see why this is an absolute winner.

Blue Lady
18 Comments
Chris Dimal

Taste wise, it was quite good. I used Bols 1575 and it contributed some fairly complex baking spice notes that made it much more distinctive. However, for some reason, it didn't foam up at all with regards to the egg white and had a slightly weird texture. Any advice?

Rhum Marianito
8 Comments
Chris Dimal

I guess I just have a wet palate. I loved this recipe and I found it balanced. 5* for sure! Slightly unrelated, I am curious about Difford's Guide's current recommendation for Clement 40% instead of Canne Bleue. I remember that the site used to endorse Canne Bleue. When going on a booze run, I actually was faced with both options but went with Canne Bleue and I feel I made the right choice.

Ironbound
6 Comments
Chris Dimal

A bit too sweet, though I did make a mix of Bourbon, rye and Calvados and added a quantity proportional to 50% ABV. Still delicious though. I used a Cachaça that would be a throwback for Difford's Guide, Capucana.

Button Hook
7 Comments
Chris Dimal

Interesting drink. It's like toothpaste (not too bad though) and apricot brandy meet. The Cognac kind of gets lost a bit. Don't know if I like it to be honest.

Chris Dimal

Pretty much what it says on the tin. Bourbon and mango are a surprisingly good match! I will say I made my own mango liqueur via maceration of mangoes in vodka and Wray and Nephew.

Mr Anthony
2 Comments
Chris Dimal

What a delicious variation of the Penicillin! The Genever adds this ever so slight breadiness which works well with the other ingredients.

White Witch
4 Comments
ian roberts

This is an excellent drink, the flavour combination reminds me of chocolate lime sweets

Chris Dimal

Yes Ian! While I haven't had those sweets specifically, the flavours I get really remind me of your description. The Orange Curacao actually just accentuates the citrus more than being a pronounced orange flavour for me.

Simon Difford

Thanks, Chris. You make a good point, and I'm on the case.

Chris Dimal

Thank you for the reply (and all the work you and your team did of course). If I may, I'd recommend you make the lime cordial (or get a REALLY GOOD one, that part is so important) and then do it 1:1.5 part ratio.

Simon Sedgley

Yes, we did a 4:3 split of the gin and cordial (Morgenthaler's) and enjoyed it very much. But perhaps the original is a 50:50 split?

Chris Dimal

Yeah, the original was equal parts. In this rendition, I prefer it as a 1:1.5 part cocktail. I do 30ml lime cordial, 45ml gin, stirred and served straight up. This proportion apparently comes from the back label of the bottle of Rose's Lime Juice.

Commodore No. 1
2 Comments
Chris Dimal

Made a version of your version of the drink (as an egg white sour with 10ml each of grenadine and raspberry syrup and no simple). Results in a nice, fruity sour redolent of a Clover Club with rum. I used Bacardi and Havana Club 3 for the rums, which to be honest, didn't provide much distinguishing differences between each other.

Chris Dimal

Definitely not a real Martini, but quite tasty. I wonder how important the sour apple liqueur/pucker is. I used a homemade apple liqueur (via maceration) alongside an 1/8tsp of citric acid and the apple was really subtle.

Chris Dimal

Sorry for the additional comment, but I would love for Difford's Guide to have its own page for the Original Gimlet. The one that is just lime cordial and gin. Believe it or not, but when you make it with a good lime cordial (like Jeffrey Morgenthaler's), it is actually really delicious and it absolutely nails the platonic ideal of a Gimlet; a dead simple, stirred cocktail with a fair bit of complexity. The lime cordial gets awakened with the gin and the dilution and it is really good, even if I still prefer this recipe. Just by a little.