CJ Grant avatar
CJ Grant

CJ Grant

  • Commenter #86
  • Appreciated Commenter #89
  • Conversation Starter #206
Penicillin
41 Comments

Tonight's version was letting some ground ginger steep in a quarter ounce of rich simple and a bar spoon of Benedictine to mimic ginger liqueur - which I had not.

The whiskey was split based Yamazaki and LAgavulin 11 - Sweet Peat. Result is tart followed by sweet smoke, with a mildy umami undertone from the smoky Scotches. I don't really get the ginger much, but notice it when I seek it - seems to grow and linger more as the drink evolves.

I didn't think I'd really enjoy this one, but was pleasantly surprised. I went a little heavy and light on the ingredients based on my expected preferences, but literally it was a "just over/under" the line.

I used a heavy portion of Nikka from the Barrel, and shorted the vermouth and orange a few mLs. It is rich and dark fruity, as though the vermouth drives things as much as the whisky.

I wonder if a little aciduated orange might bring a little spark to this one.

Love Birds
1 Comment

So this is a gin-heavy variation on the Last Word as I sometimes make it - with extra gin. I've taking the gin up to two parts (1.5oz) and brought it back to a heavy 1oz over time.

Anyhow, the opening is reminiscent of the cocktail I mention, but turns a bit more bitter in the finish. Makes sense with Cynar versus Luxardo, and I'm not sure one can improve on perfection, but it seems odd. Perhaps because the opening is leading me down a path that muscle memory should veer right and it veers left at the fork in the road (the path less traveled, for sure).

I say this because, in the end, I do like it - there is a bitter root-ish spice in the finish versus a bright, sweet, acidic one. Once I expect it, it is tasty, but I feel there could be something else there - a little spice, perhaps??

Rapscallion
5 Comments

Had to do a slightly different version using some tawny port instead of PX sherry. I also used Lagavulin's sweet peat 11yr in a slightly adjusted recipe from the "original recipe" using a heavy 2-to-1 ratio with a splash of Pernod.

I'm not a huge fan of the sweet peat, but the introduction of a modifier helps a bit. The port is missing the high note of acidity that a sherry, even PX sherry, likely would bring, I think. I'll give this one another shot with the appropriate ingredients - though I'll likely use all peated Scotch next time versus the split base of the recipe here.

Tipperary No.1
21 Comments
CJ Grant

The Irish provides a vanilla edge to the vermouth and Chartreuse sweetness, which basically describes the cocktail overall. But it’s a nuanced sweetness more than cloying, and I went 3:2:1 on the ratio (w/Powers John’s Lane).

Initially I gutted the vermouth more, but as I sipped, Chartreuse herbal spice up front and dark fruit vermouth in back.

CJ Grant

Went with a ratio from the internet, though I screwed it up and added too much Irish whiskey (and a cask strength at that). So, 2+:1:1 it the ratio I ended up with, and with Angostura dashes.

First sips I wasn't happy, but like the last time I tried this, it gets better as I sip it. It is a little hot, but that is likely from the accidental inclusion of too much high-proof main spirit.

CJ Grant

This is a somewhat savory cocktail, reminding me a bit like a morefruity, almost wine-like verion of a 100-year Old Cigar. The OJ does come through, and the peat was a nice accent (I use Lagavulin's 11yr Sweet Peat). I also think a little spice from a dash of bitters wouldn't hurt what has been built by these specs.

French Ruby
2 Comments
CJ Grant

I had to use Cherry Heering, and I adjusted by adding slightly less (a scant ounce) than the recipe called for, as I read it was a bit sweeter. It still came through bit too heavy, but I think maybe going to 3/4 might be better. I was also thinking of maybe cutting in just a little Luxardo, but that is starting to get closer to a different cocktail.

Islay Daiquiri
4 Comments
CJ Grant

The 1/3oz of honey was a bit thin, so I added another bar spoon and that balanced it a little better. This was an interesting option given the slightly odd mix of ingredients I put into the finder, but it doesn't quite work for me.

The Business
12 Comments
CJ Grant

My lime produced a bit more than the 2/3oz required, so I added a little more gin and instead of fully adjusting with the honey syrup, I added a little elder flower liqueur. It still ended up a little on the tart side, but I liked it with that acidic edge.

So not really this cocktail, which I will make in proper proportions to rate at some point.

Gold Rush
15 Comments
CJ Grant

Pretty straightforward, sweet and sour whiskey take on a Bee's Knees, I believe. I cut in a little hot honey rye I have by a local distiller and it worked pretty well.

Littlest Rebel
3 Comments
CJ Grant

This looked eerily similar to the spin I took on the Big Apple. It tastes fairly similar, though the homemade grenadine adds a little more tang. The Scotch (I used Nikka) isn't too present, but seemed to maybe round out the Apple Jack in subtle ways. Then the drink evolved such that, by the end, I was getting a nice bit of malt in the mix.

The Big Apple
8 Comments
CJ Grant

I didn't have apple juice, but did have Apple Jack. I went with an ounce and doubled the simple to counter the loss of sweetness. It turned out pretty well, like a mix of Granny Smith and red delicious apple with a touch or bourbon vanilla in the finish..

Grand Slam No.2
13 Comments
CJ Grant

Made one + half since my lime and lemon yielded more juice, which gave me some room to cut in an per-drink heavy 1/4oz overproof rum. I went a equal parts homemade grenadine (sweet tart) and simple and this thing is very good. The orange curacao plays through a bit more than expected, but combined with the tang of lemon/lime/grenadine - combining to be a little bit like a Smarties candy with those notes. The rum cuts through just enough to keep this thing from being overly candy-like overall, though.

Clara Bow
6 Comments
CJ Grant

Saw this cocktail on a variety of YoutTube channels. I never recall thinking it was something I would make, but I had all the ingredients, so I went for it.

I agree that, in any bruised/muddled mint drink, the quality of mint is key. Mine was average, so I flipped the rye and bourbon percentages and used a minty rye (Willett).

I knew the rye was strong, but still wondered about the elderflower potency, and it isn't overwhelming. It does run just on the sweet side, to me, but I love the interplay of everything.

Champs-Elysees
32 Comments
CJ Grant

This isn't in my wheelhouse, cognac/brandy only cocktails tend to fall a little flat for me (though I love them in split-based). This one hits right there - I can appreciate it, but it is a little too "smooth" for my tastes.

That said, pretty nicely balanced, though (given what I just said) I think it could take a little more Chartreuse. I think the saline is also playing a part in softening things, which I like.

As it warms (I might be odd, I often like my cocktails a bit warmer, nearing cellar temps), I feel it comes together much better.

Billionaire
8 Comments
CJ Grant

I think my lemon was extra tart, as I needed to bump up the simple just a little. I was missing the absinthe, also, so I threw a few dashes atop my poured drink. It was still a little out of balance on the sour side, but I will give this one another go to see if I get the same result.

Green Eyes No. 2
6 Comments
Robert Hughes

Love a Last Word. This is a good substitute should I ever be out of Maraschino. (Although I struggle to get a good foam with Fee Brothers)

CJ Grant

I found that going a little heavy on the dashes (5-6 or so) usually works for me, along with a decently vigorous shake. Everyone's mileage varies, of course, and Fee's doesn't bring the mouthfeel (but I'm not a fan of a true egg white mouthfeel, so it works for me). Cheers, either way!

Twelve Mile Limit
5 Comments
CJ Grant

Ok, the first time reading the comments made me assess for a second. I really like the drink, and while I don't think it is a mess, I do not really see what all of the ingredients are bringing - specifically not seeing the nuance of the rye (I used Rittenhouse).

Ignoring that critique, the rum sets the base and the cognac fills in late. It's a fairly unique evolution that piques my interest.

Smoking Hand
4 Comments
CJ Grant

Made this one with Lagavulin 11 year sweet peat (though I do not like it straight, it can work in cocktails) and Glendronach on the spirit side, regular Angostura and a dash of Fee's walnut on the bitters side. Perhaps due to the sweeter aspect of the peated Scotch, it is more balanced than I expected. I'd maybe add a [little bit of a] more aggressive Islay into the mix next time.

That said, the smoke does come through and adds a nice edge to this Boulevardier riff. I think this would work nicely with a cigar.

CJ Grant

This one surprised me. I used a spiced/tiki bitters that I know has allspice in it as my only option (it also some other, tropical ingredients), and it was a great call for me. It added a slightly tropical edge to this whiskey sour.

Crystal Ship
10 Comments
Simon Sedgley

For us, pineapple juice adds a wonderful flavour but can dull acidity and complexity. We think one can add a few drops of bitters to this cocktail to good effect. We usually go with grapefruit bitters but we're sure that others would work just as well.

CJ Grant

Thanks for the suggestion. I tried some grapefruit bitters, but that didn't have the effect I hoped. I actually ended up adding a few drops of saline solution, and that made it a bit better. I think this one just isn't for me. I am fine with that.

Crystal Ship
10 Comments
CJ Grant

Mine looks a little bit like the blue milk from Star Wars ;)

I actually made this one to specs, but it seems a little dull for some odd reason. Added it to my wish list to retry.

Anyhow, the acidity and sweetness are tamped down in the cocktail. I feel that at least one needs to step up to complete this one for me.

Andrew Craig

It has good bones; you just need to work on it a bit. I think the Fernet is a bit overpowering. Maybe lower the Fernet and increase the Aperol, or add Montenegro?

CJ Grant

I read your comment in the recent comments and saw that I could make this cocktail. Plus I like Fernet and absinthe, so I went for it.

My initial though was that it was mostly fine. But the Fernet does tend to dominate things. As such, I agree with your assessment that it has potential and that the lowering of the Fernet would be the first adjustment.

Hunter
15 Comments
CJ Grant

The cherry dominates the front of this one, and I think my decision to use a barrel-proof bourbon (thanks to reason the Difford's selected it for cocktail of the day) helped a bit as there is a bite that forces through in the end. Wastn't sure what so little Luxardo would bring, but I think it does fill in at the edges by mid-taste.

I think I'd prefer a more whiskey-heavy ratio, but this grew on me. Though I think it could be almost too easy drinking with a regular proof bourbon.