Forum

Carroll Gardens Image

Carroll Gardens

This delightfully spirit-forward riff on the Brooklyn is the most Italian American of cocktails
Back to Carroll Gardens
Add a comment
Andy Parnell-Hopkinson’s Avatar Andy Parnell-Hopkinson
25th April at 21:24
Lucano worked well. Tad too sweet for my taste (not surprising looking at the ingredients) so might split some extra dry vermouth in there somewhere.
2
reply
Tuber Magnatum’s Avatar Tuber Magnatum
30th March at 16:26
Very much enjoyed this. As Matthias tried, used Amaro Nonino as I so far have been unable to source Amaro Nardini. Reading on-line the flavour profiles of each, I am guessing there won't be a huge difference, but I would very much like to compare the two versions.
1
reply
Werd Bmocsil’s Avatar Werd Bmocsil
26th April at 18:22
I have had both straight, and yes, there isn't a big difference
2
reply
Jim G’s Avatar Jim G
1st January 2024 at 02:15
Working my way through these Manhattan like cocktails. Thumbs up. But I'll stick to my Manhattan.
1
reply
Matthias Doepner’s Avatar Matthias Doepner
20th October 2023 at 21:02
I tried this with Amaro Nonino and Michter's Rye Punt E Mes, Maraschino as recommended. A little less alcohol than 100 proof rye, but loved the herbal notes of the Amaro Nonino.
1
reply
John Hinojos’ Avatar John Hinojos
21st August 2022 at 00:57
Perfect aperitif. The rye with the other ingredients produce a very flavourful and herbal cocktail.
1
reply
Felicia Stratton ’s Avatar Felicia Stratton
10th August 2022 at 19:29
Made with Eda Rhyne Amaro Flora, lots of stirring- pure deliciousness.
1
reply