Amaro Nonino really makes this cocktail. Other subs may come close, but there's a remarkable balance and zip that only Nonino delivers.

I put a couple of sage leaves in the shaker, then run purple sage along the rim of a coupe and float that for garnish - a nice savory note that pairs well with the citrus, and the color is a bonus.

A note on substitutes: Not having Nonino I tried Averna and didn’t like it hardly at all. Now I tried with Montenegro, and it’s excellent, like adult candy. So I confirm what many others already said.

Easily one of my favorites, biggest con is its too easy to drink

This was a perfect aperitif. Flavourful, nicely bitter, and a good hint of citrus. Great colour. Easy to drink and very enjoyable.

This was tonight's aperitif choice from my Must Try list but didn't do my homework hadn't notice the Amaro lol. Too late to order the Nonino from my supplier who has it so went to the local shop and they had the Averna which is one of the alternatives listed on a list. My cocktail was dark brown though. If I make this again I may reduce the lemon. To be honest am not sure what to make of it as it doesn't taste like any other cocktails ever. My husband did make 2 litte paper planes though.

Loved this as written above. If you like that grapefruit vibe try swapping the Aperol for Amaro Santoni and a grapefruit zest twist.

Splendid. I agree with previous commenters that there is a grapefruit-like quality here. I would also add nthat this is absolutely worth purchasing some Aperol. I also tried it with Campari (all other ingredients the same), and the increased bitterness throws the drink out of balance for me.

Solid. Tried with Campari and Bulleit Rye first and now with Nonino and Wild Turkey 81. Second is better.