Are you a Discerning Drinker?
Join thousands of like-minded professionals and cocktail enthusiasts, receive our weekly newsletters and see pages produced by our community for fellow Discerning Drinkers.
Forum
Brooklyn (perfect)
A perfect Manhattan with bittersweet liqueur rather than aromatic bitters and a balancing dash of sweet maraschino liqueur. If you can't obtain Picon...
Dave D.
29th June at 02:54
I love this drink…just made me a nightcap….and I do have a bottle of Amer Picon that I keep refrigerated but “all truth told” , ordered it from Belgium during the pandemic….seems to still be wonderful?? I used my staple, Bulliet Rye…and both Martini and Rossi vermouths..
28th June at 21:12
No Amer Picon here in the USA, so made with equivalent amount of China China. I didn’t add triple sec or water, but stirred longer than normal. Really delicious and highly recommended. My choices: Wild Turkey 101 Rye, Dolin dry, Cocchi di Torino sweet, China China, Luxardo Maraschino.
10th June at 01:10
My first cocktail with Amer Picon, and it's fantastic.
Thanks to The Cocktail Seminars by Brian Hoefling for alerting me to the recipe by Jamie Boudreau. Since the Amer Picon recipe uses Amaro Ramazzotti as the base, perhaps Ramazzotti plus some orange bitters would come close. :shrug:
Thanks to The Cocktail Seminars by Brian Hoefling for alerting me to the recipe by Jamie Boudreau. Since the Amer Picon recipe uses Amaro Ramazzotti as the base, perhaps Ramazzotti plus some orange bitters would come close. :shrug:
10th June at 19:17
The original "Amer Boudreau" recipe:
https://spiritsandcocktails.wordpress.com/2007/09/09/amer-picon/
https://spiritsandcocktails.wordpress.com/2007/09/09/amer-picon/
26th May at 20:33
I made the original recipe and found it ready for improvement. Triple sec or chartreuse could be a good tip, thank you!
22nd December 2024 at 03:33
I've been looking forward to make this for about two years. I finally tracked down a bottle of the Golden Moon equivalent of Amer Picon, not being able to source the authentic ingredient in my country. I'm kicking myself for not seeing the recommendation to use China-China, as I've had a bottle of that for some time. Yet they taste fairly different, so now I get to make both...
I get the comparison to a Manhattan, but it's almost a disservice. Far superior. Top 10 Difford's maybe.
I get the comparison to a Manhattan, but it's almost a disservice. Far superior. Top 10 Difford's maybe.
13th December 2024 at 03:30
I'm surprised at the peek of the dry vermouth that came at the start. Made with Bigallet China-China (w/ triple sec added as recommended above). Very good, but this has become a bit too involved in crafting for me to want to go to often. I favor other Manhattan variants.
19th November 2024 at 04:30
What a great drink….I was able to secure a bottle of Amer Picon during Covid and still good from the fridge……used Rittenhouse and Martini and Rossi on the vermouths…..sooo good I had to have two!
2nd August 2024 at 21:26
Best Manhattan version I've had!
I used the Danish Rye Whisky from Stauning. Very dominant rye taste, so I stod by the 10 ml of Bigallet China-China and 10 ml water, but added 1,25 ml Cointreau as recommended. Vermouths were the fairly dry and bitter Chazalettes Rosso and just a plain dry vermouth.
I'll be back to the perfect Brooklyn, so much more that its parts.
I used the Danish Rye Whisky from Stauning. Very dominant rye taste, so I stod by the 10 ml of Bigallet China-China and 10 ml water, but added 1,25 ml Cointreau as recommended. Vermouths were the fairly dry and bitter Chazalettes Rosso and just a plain dry vermouth.
I'll be back to the perfect Brooklyn, so much more that its parts.