Join thousands of like-minded professionals and cocktail enthusiasts, receive our weekly newsletters and see pages produced by our community for fellow Discerning Drinkers.
Classically an equal parts three-ingredient cocktail comprising: 30ml rye, 30ml bitter liqueur and 30 ml dry vermouth. This produces an overly dry bittersweet...
Hey Simon, you’re right that the Old Pal first appears in Harry MacElhone (1927) but it was in a section called Cocktails Around Town written by Arthur Moss, a columnist for the New York Herald in Paris. In it, he credits his “Old Pal” William "Sparrow" Robinson, a sports editor for The New York Herald in Paris as the creator.
Made per recipe proportions using Bulleit Rye and Noilly Prat sweet and dry vermouths, but used half Campari and half Select Apertivo to tone down the bitterness. Served up in a coupe. We like it and will make again!
I find this gorgeously balanced. For the red bitter liqueur, I used the lovely St Felix bitter citrus ( from Melbourne) which is less bitter and more floral than a Campari.
Id say its a bit more approachable than a classic negroni. Substituted campari for Carpano botanic bitter, yielded an equally tasty drink, would certainly mix again.
Long time (3 years?) fan of this drink... No Campari on hand... Just made this twice, first with Aperol and Noilly Prat dry. Pretty good I suppose... Second attempt using 50:50 Noilly Prat and Lillet Blanc resulted in a much more accessible drink... The dry/bianco take is something I'm surprised I've yet to try... Rittenhouse Rye is my go-to, by the way. (13 Nov 2022, 1:36p)