Skip advertisement Advertisement

American Trilogy

Difford’s Guide
Discerning Drinkers (118)
Measurements in:
Serves:
1
Ingredients
1 fl oz Applejack brandy bottled-in-bond (50% alc./vol)
1 fl oz Straight rye whiskey (100 proof /50% alc./vol.)
14 fl oz Demerara/Muscovado/brown sugar syrup (2 sugar to 1 water)
2 dash Orange Bitters by Angostura

How to make

Glass

Photographed in an UB Koto Old Fashioned 30cl

Prepare

  1. Select and pre-chill an OLD-FASHIONED GLASS.
  2. Prepare garnish of fat and long orange zest twist.

Method

  1. STIR all ingredients with ice.
  2. STRAIN into ice-filled glass (preferably over a large cube or chunk of block ice).

Garnish

  1. EXPRESS orange zest twist over the cocktail and use as garnish.

Flavour Profile

No alcohol
Medium
Boozy
Sweet
Medium
Dry/sour

Health & Nutrition

Nutrition:

One serving of American Trilogy contains 159 calories

Alcohol content:

  • 1.7 standard drinks
  • 34.88% alc./vol. (69.75° proof)
  • 23.8 grams of pure alcohol

History

Adapted from a recipe created in 2006 by Richard Boccato and Michael McIlroy at Milk & Honey in New York City. By the following year it was a staple at sibling bar Little Branch bar and American Trilogy continues to be a popular cocktail at Attaboy, the bar that occupies the former Milk & Honey site.

Originally built in the glass with a sugar cube and made with three American ingredients, hence the name: rye whisky, applejack and Regan's Orange Bitters.

Review

To adhere to the original recipe, you should smash a sugar cube and then painstakingly stir this with bitters into a paste. Life is just too short to faff around, so instead, I've used pre-dissolved sugar (syrup). Depending on your personal tastes you may want to reduce this syrup to a mere 5ml or it up to 10ml. Syrup allows you to find your personal sweet spot and then consistently hit it. Once achieved, you've a delicious subtly cider-influenced Rye Old-Fashioned.

AKA: Rye Old-Fashioned

Variations/similar cocktails

Diamondback

Difford’s Shop logo
$0.07 per cocktail*

Makes a minimum of 192 cocktails.
Shipping and applicable tax calculated at checkout.


Orders are processed by a licensed Fulproof retailer. The buy now button is added simply for convenience.

Checkout

* May not include all ingredients. Price per cocktail is an estimate based on cost of one cocktail with ingredients shown above and does not include shipping.

Gallery

Comments & Discussion

P N
I am gonna try this with agave syrup
score: 2
Simon Sedgley Premium Member
We do this in a Nick and Nora glass. By general consensus, Dashiell Hammett wrote four 'great' novels, not three, but who's counting?
score: 2
Cassandra Adams Premium Member
I suppose that begs the question of who wrote three?
score: 1
Simon Sedgley Premium Member
Well, for mine, the best was Cormac McCarthy's Border Trilogy. But if we're talking film, then the three installments of The Godfather. Maybe you'd like to nominate your greatest English trio...and you're not allowed to say Harry, Ron and Hermione.
score: 1
Calvin Grant Premium Member
Eighty proof V.S. calvados 30ml. Rittenhouse bottled in bond and 7.5 rich moscovado. Hit that sweet spot! Excellent.
score: 1
Calvin Grant Premium Member
This time Laird's bottled in bond, Woodinville 90° rye and half muscovado half rich cane syrup (7.5ml). Going forward will be sure to use all dark muscovado syrup as this really makes it for me.
score: 1
Peter M Premium Member
Made with Laird's Bottled-in-Bond & Wild Turkey 101 Rye. Pretty tasty as-is. Apple is balanced. Whiskey is smoothed out. Subtle orange. and brown sugar. Not too sweet for me.
score: 2
G. M. Genovese Premium Member
I've tried this about a half dozen times now. Like y'all have suggested, reducing the sugar - in my case, to 5 ml - has resulted in a more harmonious drink. This in addition to skewing the spirit specs to 6:5, in favor of Old Forester 100-proof rye, which somehow has been a stalwart ingredient.
score: 1
Darren Companion
Made with half the Demerara and it works! Orange forward and refreshing. We had to use apple brandy as applejack is not available in Canada. Nice drink!
score: 2
Florian Ruf Premium Member
Delicious combination! I used calvados instead of applejack and this calls for a reduction of the syrup.
score: 4
Calvin Grant Premium Member
Was wondering about that. Thanks for the suggestion.
score: 1
William Johnson
This is some godly nectar, rather excellent!
score: 2
John Hinojos Premium Member
Apple flavoured, spirit-forward cocktail. Smooth and very well balanced. Used 1/2 sugar. Perfect.
score: 4

See more...

Difford’s Shop logo
$0.07 per cocktail*

Makes a minimum of 192 cocktails.
Shipping and applicable tax calculated at checkout.


Orders are processed by a licensed Fulproof retailer. The buy now button is added simply for convenience.

Checkout

* May not include all ingredients. Price per cocktail is an estimate based on cost of one cocktail with ingredients shown above and does not include shipping.