Colin Cook avatar
Colin Cook

Colin Cook

  • Commenter #134
  • Appreciated Commenter #126
  • Conversation Starter #246
Paper Plane
80 Comments
George M

To be honest when I first try it I hadn't nonino available and used Averna. I loved it. Then I try it with nonino and it was so - so . For me it totally needs to tone down the lemon by at least 5ml if one use Nonino.

Colin Cook

I also found I had to tone down the lemon juice.

Occasion
8 Comments
Colin Cook

I used Hampden Estate 8yo, Taylor’s 20yo and Mr. Black, and this turned out very well.

Colin Cook

Considering the origin of the recipe, I may try again with Havana Club 7.

Colin Cook

Enjoyed this one. I’m not big on sweet drinks, but I felt it was sour enough as written with the fresh lime juice. Tried halving the sugar syrup, but honestly didn’t notice a significant difference.

A Quiet Word
15 Comments
Colin Cook

It seems I am in the minority on this one, but to me the Maraschino liqueur overwhelmed everything else. Tried cutting the Maraschino to 1/3, but still not really to my liking.

Rosita
17 Comments
Colin Cook

Did not disappoint. As suggested in the comments I went with Angostura orange bitters. Might try grapefruit bitters next time.