Caspian Berggren

It's sweet but in a balanced way. I'm honestly surprised at how good this is. The tequila, elderflower and Chartreuse all play together really well. They're all powerful ingredients but none overshadow the other.

As have been said in previous comments I think the real crux of this cocktail is the sweetness of your grapefruit juice. To me this drink erred on the sweeter side so I think I could've done with half the sugar, but if you know that your grapefruit might be slightly underripe or bitter then I think it could be a good amount of added sugar.

I honestly really liked this but, again, the worst part of it is the vodka. Instead of playing with the apple it just dilutes the apple flavor. Next time I'll try and make this with maybe 50:50 vodka&gin and I'm convinced it's going to be even better.

Another real hitter. It's sweet but balanced by the bitterness from the Brancamenta. I didn't have any mint bitters so I used orange bitters and it worked splendidly. Instead of increasing the mintiness it contrasts it and gives the whole drink a slight candied edge. Really nice nightcap.

It's not for everyone but I love it. It's a weird combination of ingredients that work very well together. The mint really brings out the fruit in the cognac with a slight funk from the rum on the finish. Dilution is key, though - too much and the flavors drift apart and too little and it all becomes overwhelming. If you get it perfectly you'll have a nice, boozy cocktail to sip on.

I'm honestly surprised by the relatively low drinkers score on this one. The cognac, banana and sherry go splendidly together with the bitters to balance out the sweetness. I did use Bitter Truth's Boggart Bitters, though, since I didn't have the Abbotts and thought they'd be the best replacement. It's slightly on the sweet side but is a great boozy nightcap. However, don't skip the sherry! You need that figgy, burnt sugar dryness on the finish.

A crowd pleaser for sure. The gin plays well with the different juices without any of the ingredients overpowering the other. It's a tad sweet for me so I'd probably reduce the simple by half for next time. It could also be fun to replace some of the simple with a liqueur. Overall I'm pleased!

A lot less sweet than I thought it would be which is nice. The coffee liqueur worked fabulously to accent the molasses from Myers.

Not sure if I can consider the xanthan gum optional for this one. It adds just a lovely texture for the cocktail which perfectly complements the rest of the drink.

Strega and banana liqueur go very well together, and those are the two main components giving flavor, so the taste is completely fine. I don't quite understand the need to not just use all lemon vodka since it's not very pronounced. Overall a good cocktail for Strega and banana liqueur fans (of which I'm both).

I don't know, something feels off with these measurements. It says it's an 8/10 on the sourness scale with agave syrup yet I didn't include the syrup and still feel like it's maybe a 4 at most. Without the syrup it's still sweet but Tiki-balanced with the lime and bitterness. If you are looking for a Margarita-riff then this is way too sweet. I think 45:30:15ml would be a better ratio, with some agave syrup if needed.

The sherry is absolutely lovely in this. I didn't think it would register with all the other flavorful ingredients but it actually cuts through by its acidity. It provides just enough freshness and levity for you to not be overwhelmed by the agave amaro combo. If served over a big block of ice it makes for a fabulous nightcap.

I just remade this with creole shrubb and it's still great. It's a bit more funky but it's still wonderful. It's not the most complex of flavours, but if you ever have a guest that wants a candy in liquid form then this is what you should make them.

I was a bit hesitant about making this with Cruzan since I know it's a very big flavour, but after some reassurance from Difford I decided to try it out and boy am I glad I did.

The cocktail is honestly pretty egg forward which I did not expect. It's not overwhelming, just more reminiscent of a cool eggnog than I expected. The blackstrap rum and ferro china are absolutely best buds in this drink (which is what I expected and why I made it in the first place). It's honestly kind of hard to determine where the blackstrap ends and the ferro china begins but it's a fun experience nonetheless. If you wished your Espresso Martini was more interesting then this is certainly something I'd give a shot!

Yes, I think Cruzan would work.

Awesome, thanks for the reply!

It's kind of weird. With the rye and agricole rhum I used it's almost minty refreshing with the other ingredients. It's certainly interesting and worth making if you like agricole. One of those cocktails that is perfectly rated - a solid 4.

Does Cruzan work in this or would it be too molasses-heavy?

I do love the way the oloroso sherry comes through. The tequila and Cynar definitely brings an earthiness and body to the drink but the sherry takes it home by providing just the right amount of spices. It's a perfect autumn/early winter cocktail.

This is a cocktail where the garnish is really what makes it come together. Without the mint it's a delicious glass of funky wine but with the mint it really elevates the glass and becomes a proper cocktail. Be careful though, if you like sherry it will go down *easy*.

This is my kind of Tiki drink! It's fresh, complex and juicy without being overly sweet. To me the agricole plays fantastically with the pineapple juice and curacao, with the mezcal being present but not overpowering. Just a banger for anyone tired of the regular "Tiki flavor".

I kind of love that. The aged tequila, elderflower and Averna all work together with the mezcal and bitters working to just accentuate the other flavours. It's weird but it 100% works.

Accidentally used gin but it still worked fantastically. Love the hint of gin and the tart feeling on your tongue without it being sour.