Recent discussions on Difford’s Guide

8th November at 00:58
So cocchi and suze is a match made in heaven and in my bar they did'nt even talk before! This is incredible, I hardly can take the same cocktail twice in my life, but if I end here in the future: IT'S a MUST,
8th November at 00:03
This is dangerous: no alcohol taste, pure candy. I didn't have groseille but Parma+cranberry juice and syrup... I think is close -I have in my mind the taste of goseille- grosella since is very common flavor the icelollipop of grosella in my country. Is really difficult this thing about: whisky-> Irish, Japanese, Mexican, 15 y, 20 y, smoked, isley, in tequila barrack, bourbon, etc OMG so much whiskies...
7th November at 23:12
I have been trying a lot of Fernet cocktails just to avoid pouring the bottle down the drain. Not only is this the first one not to taste like menthol cigarettes, it is actually very good!!
7th November at 20:13
Hi Simon,
There are a few pre-Prohibition recipes with this title. Jack Grohusko's 1908 rendition is an "Ardsley Cooler", a simple highball with gin and ginger ale.

There is also the 1912, Jacques Straub 'Drinks' rendition with Sloe Gin, Calisaya (a Spanish liqueur of the time - now produced here in the states) and orange bitters (shaken). Bonal and Cocchi Barolo Chinato are two such commercially available products that are also similar,

This recipe originated from the Old Waldorf Astoria bar as Mr. Crockett attributed its inclusion to the "residents of a famous and wealthy community up the Hudson, by that name, furnished a good deal of patronage at the bar." Mr. Straub culled many of his recipes from the book at the Old Bar for 'Drinks', which pre-dated Mr. Crockett's book by nineteen years.

Cheers!
7th November at 19:50
Did you get the order of the dry-shake wrong? Usually it is dry-shake first, before ice shake, right?
7th November at 18:18
Trying out my new absinthe spritzer. Delicious. Rich and fruity as others have said. Perhaps a little sweet so agree with others on that - but a belter if you have that kind of tooth.
7th November at 17:10
Superb! This lady is a bandit, and she’s completely stolen my heart. Personally, I prefer it with no egg white and no syrup—Cointreau is an absolute must. For me, leaving that acidity unmasked creates an amazing structural tension. It honestly feels like a modernist painting; there’s a sharp, untrimmed diagonal of acidity cutting right through the drink. Maybe I'm overthinking a cocktail, but I just love that deliberate, artsy contrast!
7th November at 12:28
We balked at the combination of rosso vermouth and Yellow Chartreuse. So we substituted Noilly Prat dry vermouth and increased the volume of Chartreuse to 15ml. For us, this allowed the sherry to shine against elegant background herbal notes.
7th November at 12:00
We love this. While, to our taste, the recipe is really well balanced, we couldn't resist adding six drops of grapefruit bitters, just to wake it up a bit. btw the review mentions Vodka but we did it with Gin as per the recipe. We might try it with Vodka next time...maybe no dilution needed that way...we'll see.
7th November at 11:14
Very elegant and subtle...the Marsala and orange blossom water dance together seductively.
7th November at 10:19
To our taste, this easily and happily accommodates twice the volume of Lager specified. We will try it next time with an India Pale Ale, speculating that the extra hops might marry nicely with the red bitter.
7th November at 09:28
Very refreshing indeed...bravo. We think that our good host was quite game here...in our experience the beer connoisseurs can get a bit pernickity at any attempt to mess with their beloved malt and hops. We increased the volume of each ingredient by one-third and added 2.5ml Agave syrup...the syrup rounded it out nicely for us.
7th November at 07:45
Was urged to try this by Ruth (see comment below) and it did not disappoint. Subtle, elegant and slightly sweet.
7th November at 06:36
I've had two bottles of this in my time and I don't consider it good sub for blended Scotch. Tasty in its own, but it doesn't do it for me in a Blood and Sand or Penicillin. I'll stick with my Dewar’s for those.
7th November at 04:20
Tried this with St. James Rhum and the Hugo was to much for the Pineau des Charentes. So used the Clement Rhum which is softer, more earthy and grassy (a Cachaca would work as well). It was a nice match and the soft floral Wine was good along side the Rhum. Cheers
7th November at 03:15
Not spicy enough for my taste
7th November at 02:34
A fascinating flavour, bitter and harsh, used Hansen Northern Eyes for my rye. Not a regular on the list, but definitely not something I'd shy away from.
7th November at 02:33
Fascinating drink. Got better as time went on. Used 124 proof rye and it still was overshadowed by the mezcal. Would probably not make it again.
7th November at 00:59
I change for Cherry Sang Morlacco Liqueur, and Gin Monkey 47, vermouth Dolin. And since do not have Groseille I used Zocco Pazarán that is a spanish sloe berry anised -absitnhe- liqueur. A little syrup and express lemon, and was delicious. The thing is I never knew what to do with this Pacharán, but this is the way.
7th November at 00:58
This has Martinez vibes but much sweeter. A nice drink before dinner. I also used Carpano.
6th November at 23:47
Totally agree that the syrup can be cut in half as it is quite a sweet drink otherwise. I overdid the absinthe and will be interested to try using Curaçao as per original recipe as you did.
J S’ Avatar J S
6th November at 23:45
The daiquiri bitters make this drink for me, somehow pulling the whole drink together.
6th November at 23:45
Exceptional cocktail with great mouth feel from the Gomme Syrup. I must try with some actual Boker's style bitters if I can source; used a mix of Angostura and orange bitters as an approximation although not having tried Boker's not sure how close it is. Be careful with the "dash" of absinthe as it can overpower if not careful. I'm interested to try as per original recipe Curaçao and as per Mr. Carr's suggestion reducing the syrup as it was quite a sweet drink without an acid component. Highly reccommended.
6th November at 23:44
A go to for me, but I was a sherry nut before I was a cocktail nut. For me, this spec often needs 5cl more fino for that sea-spray lightness to take centre stage. One of the rare cocktails I will often tweak to taste after mixing.